denyingphoenix (logo)

I Gave You My Heart, You Gave Me A Pill

Originally posted on February 02, 2005

When I was in Philadelphia a few weeks ago my mother mentioned something that left me rather puzzled. Apparently, she had been talking to my sister about me, catching her up on a few things (remember, no talking in six years. That part is crucial here). I guess she had mentioned to her that for many years, I had suffered from depression. Needless to say, this shocked my sister.

Apparently, to others in my life, this comes as a sideswipe. I’ve had more than a handful of people tell me over the years “oh, I would have never guessed that,” with reference to my emotional status. Somehow, for some reason, the fact that I suffered from depression for years and was suicidal comes as a great shock to many I know. I can’t figure it out. How could it consume so much of my own life, but not be reflected to those I know?

As I just reread that last paragraph, it sounds so contrived. I shirk from the throngs of people who latch on to the claim of depression. Not to devalue their states of mind, but perhaps out of cynicism I think many people’s idea of depression is feeling sad for no reason, and a handleful of pills will solve it. So when I say that I suffered from depression, it is with the most serious regret and embarassment. I do not wear it proudly as a badge, status of club membership or even affirmation that I’m human and still “feel.”

See, my depression didn’t arise from anything discernable. No great tragedy or definitive happening caused it. Like a creeping fog, it swallowed me quietly over the years. If you believe in emotional makeup belonging in any part to genetics, then my family fits the bill perfectly. Like Ryan Adams, I was “born in an abundance of inherited sadness.” Almost every member has struggled with it for the grand majority of their life, and all to a greater extent than most Americans (I believe). And as far as I know (for me at the very least), no medication has ever made it go away.

Still, it strikes me as odd that people that I know (and even more so, know well) can’t recognize this element of my personality. Perhaps because of the embarassment, but to me it seems glaringly obvious. I’m not as surprised that people don’t know about my suicidal period, but I don’t think it’s too far of a stretch to see it. Truth is, for several years I was suicidal. Intermittantly, through my last 2 years in high school, and a few in college, this stalked me. I never went as far as the planning stages, but it was way more than just a passing thought. But how could this not make it to the outside? Was it not evident in my art? Have you ever talked to me? I know I never spoke of it with anyone, but still…

I feel rather betrayed by the fact that friends do not know this about me. Perhaps it’s unrealistic. Perhaps its my own self that I should be upset with, for hiding my true emotional state so convincingly that I’m perceived as stable and happy. I don’t know. I’m not even sure why it’s taken me so much by surprise, but it has.

It’s easier for me to speak of it all in retrospect. For the past two years (to the month), I’ve been in depression remission of sorts. My tendencies will always be there, genetic and not. But I’ve learned to help myself through in other ways, and am also just plain blessed for the reprieve. But it’s still something that I fight off daily…that impending, relentless march of saddness and pain.

But the question still nags me: am I an emotional con-man or do people just not know me that well?



Comments

The gloves are off on this one and I am going to shoot from the hip. First, in terms of our friends we are probably the most emotionally inept bunch of bastards that have managed to remain friends in the history of the world. We spent most of this period you spoke of protecting ourselves from each other and ourselves. So yeah we probably didn't notice the way we should. Even after my whole drama, things didn't really change we just masked them in another way.

I guess that leads to my second point. An emotional con-man? No. Emotionally distant? Probably. As much as you are the emotionally charged artistic type of our little dynamic there is still a majority of the time that I have no idea what goes on in your head. You feel like no other person I know, but it is as if you are ashamed of it. Ashamed to spark that emotion and to be vulnerable in the world’s eyes. In passing conversations you have talked of your distain for people who can't separate emotion from logic in arguments. What so wrong about emotion? It will never be logical but then again feelings were never meant to be. I think that this is the crux of your internal struggle. You want to be well thought out and logical at every step. You crave that little bit of control, but then you have no outlet for that great emotion that exists within. Obviously, your art was never enough of an outlet for that.

So who is to blame? Everyone? There is no right or wrong answer here. You can't sit here and judge the past. Just learn from it. As I sit here and reread this total bullshit I have written I have realized that I am the biggest hypocrite in the world. So I will shut up

said workingpoor

Comments are currently closed.

Did You Know?

Don't Go There...

My first purchased cassette tape was either MC Hammer's Please Hammer, Don't Hurt 'Em or They Might Be Giant's Flood.

My first purchased CD was Gin Blossom's New Miserable Experience.

Use Firefox. See columns.